A post entitled “What I’m Really Thinking” by an anonymous mother was posted in the The Guardian yesterday and subsequently shared by someone on my Facebook with some negative commentary. And because I loves me some drama as much as the next person, I went over and had a look.
What I read there caused me some rather strong mixed feelings. For starters, let me say that I have been a bottle-feeding mother. As I’ve explained in previous posts, my son has a condition known as a posterior ankyloglossia. This is a tongue-tie on the back side of the tongue. The details aren’t really important at the moment but suffice to say that due to his inability to express an adequate amount of milk, he wasn’t growing. Pumping didn’t work very well for me and in the end, my son’s life hinged on his being fed from a bottle, eventually entirely full of formula. My son is my third child and the only one who wasn’t breastfed until well past 3 years of age. Because I’ve experienced to the fullest both aspects of baby feeding, this article struck several chords with me.
The author opens up her article by talking how aware she is of the judging eyes watching her prepare to feed her child a bottle of formula:
“Those looks speak a thousand words, most of which boil down to, “How could you? We’re doing the best for our baby, why aren’t you?”
My first thought is kind of reactionary: “You don’t know that’s what they are thinking, that’s you’re own guilt talking.” Well maybe yes and maybe no. More likely both. The author mentions later in the article that she had wanted to breastfeed but that medical conditions took the choice away from her. I can tell you from experience that the guilty feelings and sadness about not being able to feed your baby as planned are very powerful, even with the knowledge that the choice to formula feed was made in the best interest of the child.
The truth is that I know exactly what she’s talking about. I remember the eyes narrowing from across the room. I’ve seen the chins lift a little higher upon realizing that I formula feed and *they* don’t. I was involved for a short time in a very “crunchy” organization (revolving around home birth) and as an extremely “naturally minded” Momma I felt uncomfortably out of place surrounded by breastfeeding moms with my son sucking down a bottle. I remember sitting at those meetings and other public places arguing with myself about whether or not those looks were truly judging me or if I was letting my own disappointment and guilt interject those feelings on what I was perceiving from their glances.
I didn’t honestly feel judged by most of them. But from some, I definitely got the haughty looks, the snide comments and questions phrased to impart judgment on my choices (if you can call not allowing your son to starve to death a choice). I can’t tell you how many times, even after frank discussion on the choice I made I received the implication that I should have tried harder, done more and that I had done my son a disservice despite everything. The reaction that irked me the most was the implication that I’m excused from my choice because I had a reason that the listener approved of. Listen, people, I don’t need your permission to feed my son anything. I don’t need your approval for my choices, either.
As I read the above article I recognize that sense of resentment and helpless anger I felt in those moments. It’s NOT just in her head. Is she, perhaps, projecting? Probably, we all do it and in all likelihood most of the people she thinks are judging her are not even paying attention to her. Yet, this reality doesn’t invalidate her frustration because that judgement is sometimes there and she isn’t entirely wrong about those baleful, disrespectful gazes.
“Certainly I feel that I have to defend my decision to bottle-feed, justify my choices so they’ll accept me.”
Oh yeah. That’s real, I’ve experienced it even from people who know my stances on breastfeeding in general. Ugh. We really need to focus more on education and rein in the judgment. If we treat all mothers with the assumption that they have the best at heart for their children, I think our message would get a lot farther.
Unfortunately my sympathy kind of wanes when I follow her article further. She suggests that as she sits there feeding her son his bottle, that the breastfeeding moms start to look envious.
“My guess is they’re thinking,”That looks a lot more efficient than breastfeeding.” You’re right, I want to tell them.”
WHAT? Ok, the violin in my head that started playing sympathetically in the background as I started reading this article just screeched to a painful halt.
My first thought is, “How would you know, you’ve never breastfed!” Also, I think she has the term “efficient” confused with “convenient”. Efficiency as it applies to baby feeding would, by necessity, have to apply to the transfer or nutrients and which method represents the best carrier. In this regard, there isn’t a shred of evidence that supports formula being “more efficient”.
She further distances herself from my camaraderie and confirms my suspicions regarding her vocabulary skills by making this statement:
“I can almost hear the deafening mental processing in those staid church halls: “She won’t have cracked nipples, mastitis, thrush or leaking milk. And her partner probably helps with the night feeds.”
I start off feeling strong feelings of understanding for her plight and end up wanting to throw something at my computer screen. Especially with her closing statement being:
“It’s really not so bad, I want to tell them, you should try it some time.”
Ugh, WHY? I mean, why take a powerful message of “Hey, quit judging me and mind you’re own business” and turn it into this plaintive, childish speculation? This appears, to my eyes, to be a classic case of twisting a perspective around so that feelings of resentment, guilt and frustrating become instead feelings of superiority and smugness. How does that make you any better than the people you think are judging you?
To make matters worse the sentiments expressed here make formula feeding look better to impressionable young women. I breastfed for 6.5 years (I actually did nurse my son for several months) and I never once had cracked nipples. It happens but is almost always related to improper latching and is easily correctable.
It’s true that if you formula feed, you aren’t terribly likely to develop mastitis or thrush (at least, not on your breasts). That’s true. It’s also true that if you never breastfeed, you’re more likely to develop breast cancer than the women who do. It’s also true that your child is more likely to develop gastro-intestinal illnesses, allergies and various infections than if they had been breastfed. This isn’t to say that if your child bottle-feeds they are doomed to a childhood filled with illnesses. Of course not. Yet, facts are facts and the research suggests that children as a whole fare better when breastfed and, surprisingly to some, so do their mothers.
None of these issues address the idea of efficiency, though, leading me to be assured that my initial guess was correct: she must be talking about convenience. I can’t agree though I’m sure that for some mothers bottle feeding is more convenient. For me it was a pain in the ass and despite some of the realities that make breastfeeding more of a challenge, I missed it and often daydreamed of those easy nights where all I had to was roll over, stick a boobie in a mouth and go back to sleep.
I knew even while I was grateful for it that formula was inferior food to breastmilk. I didn’t feel it necessary to decide that bottle feeding was “more efficient” or “better” than breastfeeding just to make myself feel better about a situation that was beyond my control. It’s not better, not even a little bit. It’s simply what needed to be done and I’m grateful it worked.
What I took away from this article was this: The few crusaders for their causes that use their stance as fuel for their superiority over other mothers are doing far, far more damage than those who are simply innocent of the truth. This woman’s disturbing article is a prime example of a mother who has dealt with the viciousness that is mom judgement and has in turn changed her thinking in self defense. I think her thinking is wrong and there is something to be said for her inability to just own her choices and move on. On the other hand, she’s a new mother. Is it really so surprising that she’s chosen to bolster herself by making her situation look better than yours? It’s human nature.
To the judgers out there, on either side, I implore you: Grow Up. This isn’t high-school, this is real life. What you say and how you treat other people ripples out from you indefinitely. That’s a heavy reality that nobody likes to think about too much (I shudder to think where some of my ripples have gone) but it’s the truth. Women who are bottle-feeding still need support, love and compassion. Being a new mother is hard enough without feeling as though you have to defend yourself constantly.











